Board Thread:Current Major Glitch Discussion/@comment-30544675-20190309225307/@comment-2600:8800:4900:C0D0:401F:45B1:62CE:D7FC-20190503034217

No, the Cocoa is a One-Off Quest. It isn't a collection item. See here: https://the-secret-society.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_One-Off_Item_Quests

I remember it took a long time for me to get one of those to drop.

-SongGoddess