Thread:Zippy130/@comment-33664764-20171102122601/@comment-27914031-20171102131041

Hi Sara! Unfortunately, that item is listed as a "One-off Item"  in this table:

http://the-secret-society.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_Quests/Part_2

A 'one-off item' does not belong to a collection, so it won't show up in the Collections window...and consequently it can't be put on your wish list. And it also is listed with a rather low percentage "Chance" (15 percent - so I guess that would mean it typically would take six or seven tries to get it). I only know of one person who was somehow able to gift non-wish-list items, and she hasn't been active in the game or the wiki lately. Sorry.

You can of course deal with night mode by playing a lot of torches. A good source of torches is the "Wishmasters" collection...and the items for that collection CAN be put on your wish list.